JournalRU✕

‹ Journal

Édouard Manet, A Bar at the Folies-Bergère, 1882

Édouard Manet, A Bar at the Folies-Bergère, 1882. The Courtauld Gallery, London

One Painting

Alone in a crowd

All around her: champagne, lights, a crowd in the mirror, life in full swing. And at the centre, a girl behind the bar, with the look of someone who is miles away.

This is Édouard Manet’s last major painting. He worked on it in 1882, already gravely ill; a year later he was gone. The barmaid’s name was Suzon, and she really did work at the Folies-Bergère, the most fashionable music hall in Paris. Manet set up a real bar in his studio, with bottles and a bowl of mandarins, and Suzon posed for him there.

Look at the mirror

Behind her hangs an enormous mirror, and in it the whole noisy hall: chandeliers, the balcony, ladies in gloves, opera glasses. Now look at her reflection. It has slid off to the right and leans towards a man in a top hat, as if she were talking to him. But there is no man in front of her. We are standing exactly where he should be.

Art historians have been arguing about this mirror for well over a century. A mistake? Deliberate? Manet was far too exact a painter to slip up on this scale. It looks as though he showed us two Suzons at once: the one smiling at a customer, and the one standing before us, looking straight past us.

States of mind never date. The dresses change; the souls don’t.

Three more details

Why we recognise her

Sociology has a term for this: emotional labour. The sociologist Arlie Hochschild coined it in 1983 while studying flight attendants: the smile is part of the job, even when something entirely different is going on inside. I spent more than ten years in the air, and I know it from the inside. That is exactly what Suzon is doing: she is on duty at someone else’s party.

And we all know the feeling. The office party where you’re meant to be the life and soul. The family dinner where you listen to everyone. The group chat where you send hearts while your mind is somewhere else entirely. The body is here; the soul has wandered off. A hundred and forty years on, the feeling hasn’t gone anywhere.

In the You Are a Painting gallery, this work speaks for energy 2 (The High Priestess): sensitivity and quiet, the gift of hearing what goes unsaid. And its shadow: listening to others for so long that you stop hearing yourself.

Look.

Before you fall in with someone else’s mood, ask yourself: “And what am I feeling right now?”

A question for yourself: where am I here in body only, and where heart and soul?

Want to see her in person? The painting hangs in the Courtauld Gallery in London. Step up close to the mirror and find the green slippers.

So which painting is yours?

Enter your date of birth and walk through your exhibition of seven paintings.

Find your painting →

More from the journal

Did it resonate?

Thank you! I’ll see your reaction.

Private Telegram channel for women“Art Detective” audio podcasts, videos and live sessions
›
Tanya Taina on YouTubevideos and reels: watch and listen
›

Tanya Taina · Art Historian of the Soul
Telegram · MAX · YouTube